Like us on Facebook
Follow us on Instagram
 

American Romantic Ruin- The 19th century Smallpox Hospital designated a New York City Landmark.

Ian Smith

More than a century ago, on the East River’s Roosevelt Island (then Blackwell’s Island) there was a gothic marvel  hospital intended to both treat and quarantine smallpox patients, many of whom were immigrants. Now, The Smallpox Hospital is a rotting ruin designated a New York City Landmark.

The hospital is situated in an otherwise undeveloped area at the southern tip of the island. Renwick designed the main building. The south wing, built in 1903-04, was designed by York & Sawyer, while the north wing (1904-05) was designed by Renwick, Aspinwall & Owen. When completed, it was a three-story, nine-bay U-shaped structure faced in granite veneer in a random ashlar pattern over load-bearing rubble masonry. The central block has a hipped roof, with corbeled crenelated parapets on the projecting sections, with a simple cornice on the non-projecting sections. Crenelated polygonal chimneys rise from the southeast side of the main block. The two wings, which project from the ends of the northwest (front) facade, had mansard roofs.

 

1872 illustration of Renwick Smallpox Hospital in New York.

1872 illustration of Renwick Smallpox Hospital in New York.source

At the center of the front facade is the main entrance. It has a porch open on three sides, oriel window above and projecting corbeled feature above the roofline. A wide pointed arch holds the main entrance. Though designed in the Gothic Revival style, all of the windows on the third floor have pointed arches rather than curves, unusual for that architectural style.

 

1922 photo of the Nurse's School on Roosevelt Island, next to Renwick Smallpox Hospital.source

1922 photo of the Nurse’s School on Roosevelt Island, next to Renwick Smallpox Hospital.source

 

1933 photo of Metropolitan nurses home at Roosevelt Island, part of the Renwick Smallpoix Hospital complex.source

1933 photo of Metropolitan nurses home at Roosevelt Island, part of the Renwick Smallpox Hospital complex.source

 

1933 photo of Metropolitan nurses home, part of the Renwick Smallpox Hospital complex.source

1933 photo of Metropolitan nurses home, part of the Renwick Smallpox Hospital complex.source

Despite the availability of the smallpox vaccine, New York City still had large outbreaks of the disease, in part because of the arrival of infected immigrants.Located on the isolated southern tip of the island in an attempt to quarantine patients, the hospital contained a large charity ward in addition to private rooms on the upper floors. In 1875, the hospital closed and became a training center for nurses attached to City Hospital, later renamed Charity Hospital. Renwick designed the building in the Gothic Revival style, and in 1903-1905, two wings with the same architectural theme were added to the school, named the Home for the Nurses and the Maternity and Charity Hospital Training School, to accommodate the growing student base.In deference to the changing use of the island, in 1921 Blackwell’s Island was renamed Welfare Island, and many of the structures there fell into disrepair as they became obsolete.In the 1950s, both Charity Hospital and the nurses school were closed, and their operations moved to new buildings in Queens.

 

This is a panoramic photo of the ruined smallpox hospital located on the southern tip of Roosevelt Island.source

This is a panoramic photo of the ruined smallpox hospital located on the southern tip of Roosevelt Island.source

 

The Smallpox Hospital on Roosevelt Island (Manhattan, New York). Designed by James Renwick, Jr.,source

The Smallpox Hospital on Roosevelt Island (Manhattan, New York). Designed by James Renwick, Jr.,source

 

Both buildings fell into disrepair, eventually becoming ruins. In the 1970s, architect Giorgio Cavaglieri inspected them both, making plans to reinforce the walls of the Smallpox Hospital.In 1972, the hospital was added to the National Register of Historic Places, making it New York City’s “only landmarked ruin.” In 1973, Welfare Island was renamed as Roosevelt Island after former President Franklin D. Roosevelt.Often referred to as the Renwick Ruin, the Neo-Gothic ruins have been illuminated nightly since 1995, in a somewhat successful effort to raise funds for stabilizing the structure.However, on December 26, 2007, a section of the north wing collapsed, adding an urgency to preservation plans.

On May 28, 2009, ground was broken on a new park on Roosevelt Island that includes plans to stabilize the Smallpox Hospital, a memorial to Franklin D. Roosevelt, and a 14-acre (57,000 m2) public area. After a $4.5 million stabilization project, the Smallpox Hospital ruins will be open to the public.

Renwick Smallpox Hospital on Roosevelt Island 2014 source

Renwick Smallpox Hospital on Roosevelt Island 2014 source

 

New York City, Roosevelt Island, Smallpox Hospital, source

New York City, Roosevelt Island, Smallpox Hospital, source

 

Looking northeast along the west face of the hospital.source

Looking northeast along the west face of the hospital.source

 

 

Looking northeast along the west face of the hospital..source

Looking northeast along the west face of the hospital..source

 

Looking east along the south face of the hospital.source

Looking east along the south face of the hospital.source

 

In the 1970s it was added to the National Register of Historic Places and designated a New York City landmark (the only ruin in that group).source

In the 1970s it was added to the National Register of Historic Places and designated a New York City landmark (the only ruin in that group).source

 

Designed by James Renwick, Jr., opened in 1856, closed in the mid-20th century, and fell into disrepair.source

Designed by James Renwick, Jr., opened in 1856, closed in the mid-20th century, and fell into disrepair.source

According to the AIA Guide to New York City, the remains of the Smallpox Hospital have the quality that architectural historian Paul Zucker, in his 1968 book Fascination of Decay, ascribed to ruins in general: “[A]n expression of an eerie romantic mood … a palpable documentation of a period in the past … something which recalls a specific concept of architectural space and proportion.”The New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, in its 1976 report designating the ruins a New York City landmark, speculated that “The Smallpox Hospital could easily become the American equivalent of the great Gothic ruins of England, such as the late 13th century Tintern Abbey in Monmouthshire, which has been admired and cherished since the 18th century as a romantic ruin,” and described the building as “a picturesque ruin, one that could readily serve as the setting for a 19th century Gothic romance.”